Previously:

Mira spun the bottle, looking at the bottle intensely as if trying to make it stop on a certain person.

The glass bottle then stopped, pointing to me.

Now:

"Uhh... truth?" I said unsurely as Mira smirked.

"Out of all the guys here, who would you hook up with?" Mira questioned as my face burst into a deep red.

"Dare! I choose dare!" I exclaimed, feeling a few stares pierce through me, making me feel more embarrassed.

"Aww... alright," Mira complied before giving me another me another mischievous look. "I dare you to kiss every non-taken guy at the table for 30 seconds."

"No way! I refuse!" I protested before sighing. "Just gimme a beer."

"You sure?" Gray asked me with concern in his voice.

"You get drunk pretty easily," Laxus added.

"Just answer the truth question," Natsu told me. I shook my head.

"If I did answer, Mira won't stop bothering me until she hooks me up with the dude," I muttered. "It's honestly worse than the dare."

"But passing out from being drunk isn't exactly an option either," Rogue commented as everyone looked at me to see what I would do.

I sighed. "Then what should I do?"

"You could always strip," Sting suggested with a smirk and pink tinted cheeks.

"Pervert!" I yelled as blood rushed to my face. I then thought about my options.

If I answered the question, Mira won't stop bothering me until I finally hook up with the guy, which could last over years.

If I did the dare, I would have to kiss like 7 guys. It'd make me look like some kind of hoe, and it'd probably make my relationship with all if them super weird afterward.

If I drink the bottle of beer, I'll probably get drunk since I suck at self-control once I start drinking. I'll probably get a hangover and a killer headache tomorrow but I might need to participate in the games early in the morning since it's the last day.

If I take off one piece of clothing, I don't think it'd really matter. I've worn thin clothing before. Heck, people have seen me naked on multiple occasions. If anyone tried anything or even looks, I could destroy them.

I shrugged and I took off my blue sleeveless shirt (the one from the last season of Fairy Tail), leaving me in my white skirt and black laced bra. (Okay I'm gonna ask this because it kinda bothers me. Does Lucy wear a bra? Like ever in the anime/manga? If she does, I've never noticed but I seriously don't think she's even worn a bra 😂)

"Hey, what are you doing?!" Sting yelled, his face exploded into a deep red as he turned away and covered his face from being flustered.

"You were the one who suggested it," I scoffed. "I might need to participate in the games tomorrow. I do not need a headache when I run through the battlefield."

"Thanks for suggesting it Sting," Orga chuckled as he looked at me with red on his cheeks. Orga instantly earned some spine chilling glares.

I felt something fall over my shoulder. I look behind me to see Laxus placing his large jacket over me. I smile. "Thanks."

"Mhm," he replied, looking away with reddened face. I simply wrapped myself in the jacket, leaving the front open so I still received fair punishment for refusing the dare, but at least I wasn't as cold anymore.

Mira just squealed. "You may not have done the dare, but I am now happy," she cooed, glancing around the table. Most of the guys at the table were blushing profusely.

Sting was still turned away, looking away from me though it was hard since I sitting in front of him. I think I saw him sneak a glance every once in a while.

Rogue simply shifted his eyesight away from me, trying to look like he wasn't bothered at all, but his red face said otherwise.

Gray just focused his gaze on the table as blood rushed to his face, trying to prevent himself from looking. Juvia was trying to prevent him from looking as well.

Natsu's face was already buried in his arms as he laid his arms on the table in front of him. He might've gotten away with looking like he was bothered, but the extreme heat he exerted from his magic and the burnt wood under his head gave him away.

Laxus was fidgeting with the bottle of beer he was drink, taking a sip every once in the while as his face became flushed with red.

"Just spin the bottle," Laxus groaned as I chuckled.

• Time Skip ~ 1 Hour Later, 9:00 pm•

It's now been 1 hour since we started playing truth or dare. (I'm rushing because I just noticed how this story already has 40 chapters but I'm barely halfway through this book)

Wendy was dared to asked Romeo out, in which she did and he said yes. Mira, of course, started fangirling.

Erza's question was "who do you hate the most out of everyone in the circle". She answered with "I hate no one here". She was told that wasn't a real answer, so Erza ended up chugging a bottle of beer, which didn't quite knock her out yet but she was a little buzzed.

Natsu chose dare, so Mira dared him to let me sit on his lap for the next 3 rounds. Despite my protest, I sat on Natsu's lap for the next 3 rounds.

Gajeel chose dare and Mira let Levy decide his dare. Levy just dared Gajeel to let Natsu draw on his face for 30 seconds. At the end of the 30 seconds, Gajeel had some... indecent drawings in permanent marker on his face.

Gray chose truth, and so Mira asked him "who was the first girl from the guild that you liked romantically". He hesitantly said I was the first girl from the guild he liked romantically. He immediately earned a few glares while Juvia cried and chased me. Since I was still on Natsu's lap though, he helped protect me from Juvia.

Callista was dared to ask one of the Meraki Parastin boys. After a few minutes of discussing who she should ask out, she declined the dare, obviously. She had to drink a whole bottle of hot sauce though and she literally breathed fire. Natsu thought it was cool.

Rogue chose truth and his question was "what would your dream girl be like". His answer? 'Smart, sweet, and optimistic.' Mira told him that the description matched me, in which he replied with "I know".

Laxus chose dare. He was dared to let me do his makeup. Of course he didn't want to, but he figured it wouldn't be bad. Mira brought out a makeup box, that she just so happened to have. I did Laxus' makeup while I wore his jacket, as I had no top on and I was still in my bra. I think that's why Laxus' had a dark blush when I did his makeup.

By the end of the game, Levy and  Juvia were knocked out from drinking. Few people were half naked or buzzed after a few drinks.

Now, we're in the present. I'm no longer on Natsu's lap and Mira just ended the game.

I, along with other people, put their clothes back on after truth or dare ended. We've all eaten dinner at the bar already, and the Sabertooth wizards said they were gonna leave to make a plan for the last day of the Grand Magic Games.

"Oh wait! I exclaimed before the Sabers could leave. They all looked towards me and waited as I made my way.

"Could you give this to Yukino? And tell her I'll visit her before the games start tomorrow?" I asked as I summoned my celestial spirit keys into my hand, holding up the keys. Laxus' jacket was still hanging off my shoudlers, as I have not given it back yet.

"Of course, Lucy-sama," Rogue answered, giving me a small smile as I dropped my celestial keys into his hand.

"We'll see you tomorrow, Star Girl," Sting beamed while waving.

"Bye!" I waved back as the Sabertooth mages left the bar.

I walked back to the table where we played truth or dare. Wendy was no longer at the table, as she was with Romeo, planning their date. Mira wasn't there anymore either since she was busy serving drinks.

Levy was in Gajeel's arms while Juvia laid her head on the table while they slept.

"Oh, Laxus," I said as I sat down between him and Callista.

"Hm?" Laxus hummed in response as he looked at me.

"Here's your jacket back," I replied, starting to take Laxus' jacket off.

"No, it's fine," he told me, stopping me from taking his jacket off. "You're wearing a sleeveless shirt when it's cold. You can give it back to me tomorrow."

"You sure?" I questioned.

"I'm sure," Laxus assured as I gave him a genuine smile.

"Thanks."

"Alright, we need to come up with a plan for tomorrow," Erza exclaimed, walking to our table with Mavis behind her. "First Master is here again to help us."

"But we don't even know what the last day's gonna be like," I pointed out.

"Actually, the last day is mostly the same every year," Gray informed me. "It's usually something to with all 5 of the team members, not including the reserve. It just has a different twist every year."

"Oh, alright," I replied as Erza sat down and Mavis stood on our table. "So there's a chance I may not participate?"

"There is a chance," Mavis beamed, thinking of a strategy to win the 5th day. After a few minutes, she said, "But there is a 89% chance you do participate."

"Aw man," I whined as I slumped in my arms.

Mavis just looked at me with pity before returning to her usual smile. "Alrighty, so here's the plan."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Just a quick thanks to everyone for 3.4k reads and 210+ votes! It really means a lot to me since I really do enjoy writing.

The chapters may or may not be a little more fast-paced from now on because there are already 40 chapters but I'm barely halfway through the story-