A/N: This part two was requested by again, a lot of you people that I could even mention again.

Peter Pan X Reader

(Y/N) was carefully guarding the house with one hand on her bow and the other ready to take the sword out of its sheath. Every single one of the kids were asleep. (Y/N) was glad that they could sleep well since neither one of them really knew the real reason why they're there. They all thought that their parents decided to let them have a play date with other kids. Well, the older ones knew better but were all agreed not to say anything for the sake of the little ones. 

After an hour, there was still nothing that has happened. (Y/N)'s hand subconsciously went to the drawing on her wrist. She swallowed the lump in her throat. Telling those kids that story made her feel as if there was a burden lifted off her shoulder. She took in a deep breath and sighed. She missed Peter but being able to help other people felt good.

Suddenly, she heard a creak of the floorboard. She swiftly turned her head and saw that one of the boys were getting up. She rushed towards him.

"What's wrong?" She asked.

The boy didn't reply. His eyes were open but he seemed as if he was in a trance. She's never seen anything like this before.

The boy stood up among many others and left. (Y/N) tried to stop them but she couldn't. She had to use magic. (Y/N)mall learned magic when she was in the Enchanted Forest. She was taught by a good witch who was now somewhere in Oz. But (Y/N) didn't always use her magic since it felt really draining.

She closed her eyes and gathered all the emotion inside of her. She said a spell that locks down the entire house so that no one else, but her, could leave.

Then she left and followed the boys who left. She noticed that they were all heading towards the same direction. (Y/N) swiftly climbed a tree and saw that there was a bonfire in the middle of the woods. She had a strong hunch that there might be where they were going.

She followed them and tried to get rid of the trance that they were in but the magic was too strong. She kept on following them until she saw that there were other boys that were headed towards the fire.

Since the boys were actually on a slow pace, (Y/N) went first to the bonfire. There were other boys there dancing around. And she saw a hooded figure in the middle playing a pan. She concluded that this person might be the one who's controlling all the kids.

She took her bow and arrow and shot an arrow at him. But to her shock, he caught it just a few inches before it hit him. He stopped playing but the boys were still dancing. (Y/N) couldn't even hear the music which confused her. She took another arrow and shot it at him but he caught it once again.

"I thought you would've learned the first time," he spoke up.

"Well, I'm not a fast learner," she quipped.

The boy then took off his hood and faced (Y/N). Their faces were now both in equal shock.

"Peter?" She said softly.

"(Y/N)," he smiled.

He walked towards her and was about to hug her but (Y/N) stopped him by punching him in the gut.

"Ow," Peter groaned. "What the bloody hell was that for?"

"That was for leaving me back in London."

(Y/N) never really thought that that would be her reaction when she sees Peter again. But that just happened.

"That was for your own protection."

"Protection," (Y/N) scoffed. "I can protect myself."

"Sorry," he apologized. "I underestimated you."

"You surely did."

(Y/N) didn't know when it started, but now she has tears on her eyes. Maybe it's because she's finally found the person she's been looking for for so long. She isn't that emotional but finally her search was over. All that waiting finally paid off.

"But when I searched for you in London, you were gone."

All the anger seeped away. "You- you came back for me?"

Peter nodded.

"But the boys. The kids. Why are you kidnapping them?" She asked.

"I'm not. When the boys feel alone and lost and hear the sad tune of my pan, they come. Then I take them to Neverland and give them a good life."

"Those boys have families. People who care for them."

"They don't want to go back."

(Y/N) opened her mouth to speak but she couldn't think of anything else to say to win this argument. She took a step back from Peter and started to walk away.

"Where are you going?" Peter caught up to her.

"For so long, I've longed to go back to Neverland. To be with you again. But will you let me go back and will you let me stay? All these battle scars might have been for nought if I don't go back with you but it will certainly be for nought if you throw me away once again."

"I didn't- I just wanted to protect you. Can't you understand that?"

"I know," she sighed.

"It was hard for me to let you go."

"Now do you want me back?" She asked.

"I always did."

She sighed and didn't argue anymore. "Okay," (Y/N) smiled. "Just let me do one thing."

She walked into the bonfire and took in a deep breath. Peter watched in anticipation what (Y/N) was going to do.

Gathering all her positive emotion from happy memories, she let her magic spread. She gave every single boy a happy memory. She helped them not feel so lost. Then, she placed them back inside the house that's not locked anymore. Then, she placed a letter for the children and that they'll know that she's found Neverland and for the townspeople to think that she sacrificed herself so that their children won't be kidnapped.

When she was done, Peter was there to catch her when she fell. She felt so weak. So drained, but she still felt happy.

"Let's go back to Neverland," she smiled. "I have a lot of stories to tell you and the Lost Boys."

A/N: This was supposed to have a sad ending haha. An ending where (Y/N) finds out that she'd rather be protecting people then being with the guy who threw her away.

But yeah, I didn't think you guys would want that hahaha especially since a lot of you guys requested this second part.

Oh right, I only have two years left of high school but I feel really emotional saying goodbye to the school and curriculum I've known ever since I was a kid.

Read

Love

Comment

Vote

Share

Follow

❤️ Once_Upon_A_Glade