Toffee Returns

Background color
Font
Font size
Line height

3rd POV

Sometime after Ludo has seized the Mewni royal throne, he orders a choir of Mewman children to sing songs in his honor, but he tosses them into the sky with Levitato when they sing off-key. By this time, Ludo has assumed complete control of the kingdom and commanded the people to worship him.

On his way to the throne room, Ludo gets ambushed by a person in a rat costume. The person in the costume reveals themselves to be Star Butterfly, who demands to know where her father is. However, Star is quickly captured by Ludo's spider, and, following his wand's orders, Ludo has her imprisoned in the dungeons. As Star is carried away, she warns Ludo that Toffee is controlling him through his wand. After Star is imprisoned in the dungeons, two people in a rat costume appear outside the dungeon doors and knock out the rat guard. There is some fighting, and the figure opens the door and approaches Star.

It pulls off its mouse head to reveal Marco Diaz and Y/n. Star gasps "Marco? Y/n?" "Star! Hiii-" Marco was about to chop the cuffs, but Y/n stop him. "You should probably use the key instead of trying to chop it." "Oh,...yeah, your right *chuckle and unlocks Star's hands* we can't believe you're here; I was thinking we'd maybe never see each other–"

Star hugs Marco and Y/n. Her horns are poking Marco and Y/n the chin. "Star?.... Your horns... *whispering* are poking us." Star whisper back "Take them off." Y/n takes them off and returns the hug. There is a rustle. "Y/n, your stomach just made a weird noise." "That wasn't me" "That was supposed to be a surprise. I brought you this... [lifts his hoodie] box of Captain Blanche's Sugar Seeds. Sorry, there's none left. Me, Y/nand your dad ate 'em all when we were locked up in the dungeon." "Aw, man, you guys got to eat cereal together in the dungeon? Jealous." Y/n chuckled then got serious. "Star, we....got....bad.....news....your dad, he–" Star interrupted her. "Yeah, I know. Ludo tev-a-tay-tato-ta-potato'd him. If Ludo mastered it, it can't be dangerous."

Marco doesn't agree with her "I think it's kinda bad, Star." "So, do I. He never went back down" "Marco, Y/n, honestly, he's been through worse. Way worse. I think we have bigger problems right now." "Well, you're in luck, Star. [whistles bird call, nothing happens, sighs] Come on, guys, we practiced this. [bird call] Mourning dove!"

"That's not what doves sound like on Mewni." "Argh! Just get down here." Foolduke, Ruberiot, and Mime Girl drop from a ventilation shaft. "Star, allow me to introduce... la resistance!" Marco puts on a beret, in a French accent and puts one on Y/n. "Why me?" Y/n ask. Marco unfolds a simple map of the castle.

Marco starts explaining his plan. "The easiest way to depose a ruler is to destroy his credibility. So, [putting objects on map]. And this 650 dollars is us. And this feather is bird and spider. Normally, they're always with him or nearby, except bird and spider break to feed every five hours. When he's alone, we take this air duct to the throne room. And that's when Foolduke hits him with..." Foolduke pulled out a Rubber chicken.

Marco shook his head no. Foolduke squeezes rubber chicken "Uh, how about whoopee cushion?" Marco signs in frustration and runs his hands over his face "No, we talked about this before. Ruberiot?" "I have a ripping parody song I've been working on." "We're wasting our time!" Y/n yelled. "He is great at ruining people's lives with songs.

Marco, it seems like you guys are just kinda playing pranks." Star agreed with her. "Yeah, we're still working on that payoff part." "Okay, look, what you're doing here is, like, totally super-admirable, and Marco, you've never looked cuter in that beret, but Ludo is not the problem here. Toffee is controlling him. And I don't think a song is gonna fix things–"

Ludo enters the dungeon unexpectedly carrying a tray with tea. "Actually, Star, I was thinking ab" He drops the tray. "Guards!" Rats storm in. All six of them besides Star are chained to the wall. "You'll never silence the resistance!" Ruberiot shouts out. Ludo points at Star "You! You're coming with me! Levitato." Star struggle "Whoaaah! What the heck? Oh, of course."

Ludo and Star leave the room. They are now outside on a balcony. He releases her from the spell. Star stood up and cross her arms over her chest "All right, Ludo. What are you gonna do now? Levitato me again? [sarcastic] Oh, I'm so scared. That was the worst." "Actually, you said something earlier about my, um... about my... [clears throat, puts wand hand behind his back] about my W-O-N-D."

"Oh, so now you want my help?" "Of course, I want help! I've been talking to my own hand! It keeps me up all night! I can't sleep, I can't think! I can't focus on my new job as Mewni's beloved monarch!" The wand hand glows green and points at Star.

"Wha–? Oh, hello. Yes, of course. I... no... what? Of course, I'm beloved! Didn't you hear the song?" Star screams "Ludo! Why do you think I came here without a wand?" Ludo responds "Because... you were surrendering?" "It's corrupted! By Toffee! He's in the wands, Ludo." Ludo pauses, the words that Star said repeating over and over in his head.

"In the wa... In the wands?! [pauses, screams] Get him out! I don't want to be corrupted! I don't want to be corrupted! How did he even get in there? How did he even get in there?!" "I don't know how he got in there. The last time I saw him, he...Ohhhhh!" Ludo groans in disgust "Yuck!" Star sigh "Ludo, please. I think I know how to get Toffee out." "And then I can go back to being a beloved monarch?" "Give me your hand." Ludo holds out his wand arm. Star walks over to it, kneels, and begins whispering to it. The half-star turns black.

With Marco and Y/n
Ruberiot, Foolduke, Y/n, and Marco are chanting. "We are the resistance! We remain insistent!" Some rats open up the door, clearly annoyed. "We're the resistance!" "You can't silence the resistance! And gimme back my beret." "Forget your beret! We're in a dungeon." The rats ignore his request and approach him and Y/n armed.

"Wait, why are you...? Actually, the resistance can be quieter." "Get it away from me." "Be brave, Marco! Y/n! You may fall, but the resistance lives on!" Ruberiot said while Foolduke still chanting. Marco & Y/n "What?!" "I'm pregnant! so, you better get that away from me or you will get that thing inside you!" Y/n growl.

"Wow, those mood swings are really powerful....and kinda scary. Remind me to mess with you're mad." Y/n glare at Marco. The rat guard holds up a spear to their face. "Why just us?" "Ruberiot!, Foolduke! You guys are so dead to me!!" Marco and Y/n closed their eyes tightly. The rat holding the spear is suddenly beaten up. Marco and Y/n open their eyes, look at the beaten rat then look up and smile wide. Buff Frog throws rats against the wall, creating a hole.

"Karate boy, Angel girl" Marco & Y/n "Buff Frog!" "And..." Steps aside to reveal Queen Butterfly. "Marco! Y/n!" Marco & Y/n "Queen Moon?!" Queen Moon slashes Marco's and Y/n's chains open. "Where's Star?" "Ludo took her. We have to find him before he does something awful." "He already sent your husband in the air and never returned." Buff Frog gesturing to the resistance and asks.

"What about arts-and-crafts friends?" "The resistance will live on without us." Y/n glare at Marco, who gave her a nervous smile and a nervous laugh. "Let them go Buff Frog," Y/n said with a serious face. Ruberiot shakes his head yes "Thank you." Foolduke nods "Yes, thank you." "But you guys need to get out of here now." Mime girl, Ruberiot, and Foolduke ran.  Marco, Y/n, Moon, and Buff Frog exit through a hole in the wall Buff Frog made.

Buff Frog picks up the two of them and hops from balcony to balcony. He nearly misses one and clings to the edge. Star is on an adjacent balcony. Moon getting off Buff Frog's "Star!" Moon, Y/n, and Marco get on the balcony and try to get a closer look at Star. Buff Frog is still on the ledge. Star waves "Hey, Mommy. Hi, Marco. Hello, Y/n." A green ghostly Millhouse escapes from Ludo's wand hand.

"I, uh... I'm sorry, you guys." 'No! Not that, please anything, but that.' Y/n thought as she had a flashback when she remembered when Star used the whispering spell as she was held captured by Toffee. Millhouse whinnies. Moon tearing up. "The... The Whispering Spell. [slamming fists] No! Star! You get... you get away! You run away from there!" "It's too late, Mom." Ludo asks "So does this mean that everything's back to normal?" Star replied, "It's not over yet."

"What do you mean it's not–" The wand begins to explode. The entire tower and balcony Star and Ludo are on is obliterated. Marco, Y/n, and Moon are shocked. "Star!" "Please!" "No!" "No, no, no! Buff Frog, we have to go now!" Queen Moon shouts. Buff Frog grunts as he grabs the two while Y/n jumps on his back. Buff Frog hops on the ledge. They run into the crater where the tower used to stand. Moon uncovers Ludo from some of the debris. Moon grab Ludo and shook him. "Ludo! Where's Star?"

Ludo's eyes light up, pink. Star wakes up, gasping. She is waist-deep in a dark green ooze. "Where am I?" Moon asks Ludo "Where is my daughter?" Star from inside Ludo answered "Mom! Mom, mom! I'm in here!" 'I know that voice...It's Star! She's alright.' Y/n thought. "Star? Is that you?" Moon asks. "Yes, it's me!" Star replied. Moon hugs Ludo "Oh, thank goodness! Oh!" She kisses Ludo. Marco, Y/n, and Buff Frog look in disgust. Star/Ludo tries to push her mom away and giggle "Mom, stop it."

"Oh, Star! Where are you?"  Star inside looked around, but nothing "Well, I-I'm totally fine, but, uh, but, ah... I don't exactly know where I am." "That's okay, sweetie. The important thing is, you're safe. Just stay right there. [starts breaking up] And no matter whe– we'll find you–"  Moon's voice breaks off, as she flickers out of existence from Star's perspective.

The ooze forms waves. While that was happening, outside, y/n suddenly got dizzy and try to stand up straight.  "Mom? Mom, yeah, can you repeat that? I–Y/n!" Outside, Ludo's eyes close. "Star? Are you still there?" Marco turns his head to Y/n and sees her about to faint. "Y/n!" Ran toward her and caught her in time. "What happens? Is she okay?" Buff Frog asked. Marco checked her pulse. "She's fine. Don't worry, she'll wake up." Marco started having flashbacks all those times Y/n fainted when there were green magic or-. Marco realized what was happening and that Toffee was either trying to talk to her or he is still alive.

With Star
"Mommy? Oh, what is happening?! Mom!" Star yelled out hoping to get an answer. A large wave of ooze emerges behind Star. A giant eye emerges as it opens its lid from the ooze.  Star gasps and tries to swim away "Ohh, crazy eye, crazy eye, crazy eye!"

A large geyser of ooze erupts, revealing a large claw. Star quick swims the other way only to be trapped by another claw. The eye starts to lift up, revealing another eye, a mouth, and a neck. Star panics. "Hello, princess." "Toffee?! Aha! I knew it! I knew it was you all along! Wha... wait. Is all this goop you?" Toffee smiles saying nothing. "Ew, ew, ew, ew, ew, ew, ew."

Star tries to get the goop off. Toffee swimming around Star "You don't even recognize your own magic when you're swimming in it." Star lifting up something gold "This stuff is the magic?" "It was. Until I got here." Toffee touches the gold magic. It turns dark green. "Oh, boy, that's not good. Mom, we've got a problem!" "Only I can speak to her now."

Outside

Toffee opens up a connection to the outside. Ludo opens his eyes. They are green. "Hello, Moon." Moongasps "Toffee." Marco and Buff Frog gasp as well, but I all did was only stare at Toffee. Ludo/Toffee starts hovering in mid-air. "Give us back Star." Moon demand. "Oh, of course. But I'd like something from you first. Something that belongs to me."

Holds out arm with the missing finger. 'I knew it.' Marco and Buff Frog look at me then Toffee. Moon looks at Marco, unconscious Y/n, and Buff Frog then at Toffee so confused about what to do. Nevertheless, she reluctantly gets out his finger. Marco's eyes stared at me, I could feel it in my soul, asking if "I really knew what I was doing?" to me. "Take it." Moon holds it out.

Inside Ludo
"No, Mom, stop! I can take him! Just hold on! Please!" Star swims toward Toffee's ooze form, but he pushes her away with an effortless gesture. Star tries again, swimming much faster. Toffee misses her a few times before grabbing her by the hair. "Poor little Butterfly. You've lost your wings. [to Moon] Now, your Majesty......do we have a deal?" Moon lays Toffee's finger in his fingerless hand. It magically fuses back. Toffee begins to ooze towards the ceiling. Toffee said to Star "Goodbye." He continues to ooze upwards. "No, no! Noooo!" Star falls into the black ooze.

With Y/n (1st POV)
I gasp and sit up. "Wha-Toffee! Where Star?!" Got up and looked around me for any sign of Toffee or Star, standing on a raft, but it was black and dark green ooze. I remembered was in the same place. "Why am I here?" I start rambling softly. "I don't understand......Toffee always loves putting clues for me to answer.....could...this...be one of....his clues?" The ooze move and I try to keep my balance.

"Toffee, please show yourself." I whimper. An eye appeared, the wave got bigger and I fell off the raft, I only saw a glimpse of what looked like a claw and my eyes widened when I noticed one finger was missing. Everything went black. You would think I would wake up after that, but I didn't and got transported to somewhere else.

I look around my surroundings then I heard footsteps. I slowly turn my head, gaps at the figure standing over me. "T-Toffee?" "Yes, It's me, my love." "Bu-b-but....why all this? and what is going on?" Toffee put a claw on my cheek and kissed my other cheek. "My love......Thank you...you were the one who showed me what love is and that there was a way to change history." "What are you saying?" "I'm leaving soon....we aren't meant to be.....I will miss you though." "Toffee" It went black once again.

Outside
I gasp for air and woke up in Marco's arms. "Y/n! Are you alright?" "Yeah, what-Toffee! Star!" I got up and gasp at  Ludo's eyes turning from green to black, and his body becomes lifeless. Ludo then extends his arm, and Toffee grows from Ludo into his reptilian form (his suit grows back too). He then vomits out Ludo.

Toffee looks at his arm, as the scar on his finger fades entirely. He moves his fingers. "Where's my daughter?" Moon asks Toffee. "Where's Star?!" Marco also asked. I stood on the sideline with Buff Frog. Toffee, still in disbelief over being alive, hasn't seen me yet, extends his hand outwards and crushes the black half-star fragment to dust. "She's gone." Walks away. Buff Frog, Marco, and I gasp. Moon Butterfly's eyes tear up, her cheek diamonds and arms grow dark purple veins. Her diamonds then turn dark purple.

She roars and chases Toffee. Toffee just sighs then turns around and strikes Moon's punch aside. He blocks a few more punches from Moon and catches her fists. Moon breaks free and holds Star's wand to his chest. 'She's using the spell? But the last time she missed.' Moon starts casting the spell

"I call the darkness onto me from deepest depths of Earth and sea! From ancient evils unawoken, break the one who can't be broken! From blackest night I pledge my soul and crush my heart to burning coal! To summon forth the deadly power to see my hated foe devoured!" The spell does nothing; Moon cries while Toffee holds up her arm with the wand.

"Are you finished?" Toffee asked unfazed by what happened. Marco punches his fist through Toffee's body. His eyes are also tearing up. Toffee's body regenerates instantly. I what he was about to do next, so with tears in my eyes, I ran fast and pushed Marco out of the way only thrown into a boulder.

Toffee's eyes widen at the fact he just threw me into a boulder, he wanted to run toward me and apologize, but he knew....he couldn't....and he didn't understand why. It's like he forgot me. Moon didn't see his reaction.  Buff Frog and Marco run over to help me, while Toffee grabs Moon, shoving her into the ground, then turning to walk away apathetically. Ludo grabs Toffee's pant leg "Please... just tell me. Did I have any part to play in this?" Toffee's simple answer was "No." Ludo's beak trembles, and Toffee continues to walk away.

Buff Frog claps trying to wake me up "Angel girl. Wake up." My eyes slowly open. "Oh! Thank god! You're alright!" Marco hug me then let go of me. "Where-" I rub my head to ease the pain. "Uh, I think the queen, uh, needs help." Buff Frog moved to the side and I see Queen Moon is attempting to gather the particles of the broken star fragment and assemble them in Star's wand. I got up and walk toward her with tears in my eyes again.

I had dried tears on my cheeks. "Come on, come on. Why won't you fit? Come on." Moon mumble while in tears. "Queen?" I wanted to say something, but my throat was dry and if I open my mouth I would start to cry. "M-Maybe if I-I put the wand back together, it'll, it'll, it'll bring her back. But this piece won't fit." Moon sobs softly. Marco holds up a piece "Here. Try this one." I hold up two pieces "These might fit." while sniffling.

While Marco and I help Moon, I would search for Toffee, looking at my surroundings and I saw him walking away never looking back. 'Changing history? I mean....everything is in the past, but it can change once learning more.' I realized he meant and that there was a way to get through to him.

Moon, Marco, I, and Buff Frog trying to piece together the wand. The ground shakes, and the wand levitates into the air, filled with gold light. Before their eyes, the star crystal is repaired, and the wand changes form. Star, golden-colored, appears out of thin air and reaches out to grab the wand. She transforms, growing much larger horns, four additional arms, and large golden wings. We were in shock, but happy that Star was back and better than ever. 

I look at where Toffee at, Star was gonna destroy him if I don't do something. So, I ran to Toffee while everyone was busy. "Star!" Moon shout out in happiness. "Hi, Mom!" Star said in a distorted voice. Moon waves "Hi, sweetie. Don't you look lovely?" "Where's Toffee?" Moon points to him walking away. Star blasts him with a surge of golden light. He roars as he disintegrates into nothing but bones and ooze. Or so you thought, but I pushed him out the way and was about to get blast...., but I felt someone pushing me down with them and got on top of me protecting me from the blast.

Star flutters down to the ground, transforming back to her normal self and gasps. "Star!" Everyone, except me, ran to her. Moon hugging her "Oh, my baby!" Marco joins in the hug and Buff Frog jumps on top of everyone. "Hi." "Hi." "Wait?......Y/n!" Star got up and ran to me with everyone following her. When they got to my location, Moon and Buff Frog were shocked except for Star and Marco. Toffee was still on top, rising slowly, trapping me by his arms next to my head.

"Why?....why help me? Do you have any idea what could've happened to you?! Are you nuts!" Toffee asks while lecturing me without knowing it. "You have forgotten me? You asked me a similar thing back then in the past." He looks t be confused. I continue.

"You don't deserve this kind of treatment and I'm you I'm not from here, I shouldn't even be here,  but that was in the past and I probably changed the

You are reading the story above: TeenFic.Net