Two days later:
Your pov:
         Here I was again, at another game. (Y/B/N) begged me to come, claiming there was a surprise waiting for me afterwards.

(C/N)'s pov:
         I was on the pitchers mound, throwing the ball to the catcher to warm up for the next inning, when I spotted (Y/N) in a sweatshirt and sweatpants and a messy bun. Dang, even then she looked good. Seeing her made me even more nervous after the game. I'm so glad her brother was understanding about me breaking apart of the bro code.

After the game:
(Y/N)'s pov:
           When the game ended with a big win for us, and the boys were done cooling off, we were  about to leave, when (C/N) stopped us, handing me a letter. It read:

"To (Y/N),
               I have liked you for a while now, but I have a few questions. Please write the answers on the line next to each question. I know this is a bit dorky, but I can't do this while talking to you, I'd get too nervous.
(Bold-The answer, Not bold-the question)

What's the first name of the actor who played the main character in 'The Fresh Prince Of Bell Air"? Will

What's the opposite of the word me? You

And the opposite of the word stop? Go

And of the word in? Out

What does w/ stand for? With

What's the opposite of the word you? Me

Now, go back and read your answers as a question, and imagine me asking it to you. What's your answer?
                                  -(C/N)"

As tradition, I'll leave it up to you.