The Brotherhood Of Horsemen

What would happen if the four horsemen were a modern day brotherhood that hunted supernaturals? And what would happen if after the death of their brother pestilence they find that he has been replaced with a woman?

Who will you ship?

Death? The man who can't touch anyone without killing it-- except the other horsemen.

War? The fight crazy man who needs the soft spoken woman?

Or Famine? The likeable man who's always hungry.