Dean's POV:

Athena said we couldn't do anything when her brother would be home soon. Even though she cockblocked me, I agreed with her figuring it would probably not be great for her brother and I's friendship if he walked in on us having sex.

She forced us to go back downstairs so we wouldn't have as much privacy, being that her twin brother's room was down there. 

I waited for about twenty minutes before Keith got home, and Athena and I watched him drive in.

"Hurry! Hurry!" Athena panicked as she pushed me off the couch, trying to make it seem like we weren't just cuddling. 

I had texted Keith earlier about coming over to see him, and he surprisingly agreed. I wanted to apologize for everything that has happened in the past, not just because I was sleeping with his sister, but also because I genuinely felt bad.

"Hey Keith!" I say happily. I haven't seen him in about a year and a half.

"Hey, man!" He says back with a smile on his face making me feel even more guilty about the past.

We make small talk for a while, but I finally got rid of my pride and apologized.

"Look, I just wanted to say, I'm really sorry about what happened a few years ago. I really miss seeing you and I hope we can put the past us." I say somberly.

"No worries! Things happen, I guess." He was always the most forgiving person I'd ever met. Though I'm sure he'd still like to kick my ass. I can't even imagine what he'd do if he found out about Athena and I, but I've always liked a good fight.

After a while of more talking, Keith and I decided to go out to the bar so we could get to hangout more.

Keith said I could spend the night which I happily said yes to. Maybe I could sneak away once he fell asleep and see Athena. 

Athena nominated herself as the designated driver so Keith and I could get to spend more time together.

✾

"Damn, that girl is kinda hot." Keith said slurring his words slightly.

"How can you tell? All I can see is the back of her!" I ask him while laughing.

"I don't know she just gives me good vibes."

"Go talk to her then!" I urge him.

"Ok, ok, I'll be right back!"

I pick up my phone while Keith flirts with the girl, noticing a text from Athena.

Athena: Can't wait for tonight;)

She means sex, right?

Me: Neither can I... maybe I should head back now.

I didn't know what the hell she was talking about, but my drunk thoughts hoped it meant I could see her naked.

She is so beautiful. She has a slim, small figure, and is so petite. It makes me feel strong being around her because I could protect her so easily. I could also destroy her with my dick if I wanted to, which made my ego happy.

Keith interrupts my thoughts about his sister and comes back with an awkward facial expression.

"What? It didn't go well?" I ask him.

"Dude, that girl was your sister." He said making me feel a hint of anger. But that anger quickly went away as I remembered what I was doing with his sister.

"What?!" I turn around looking in the crowd. Sure enough it was my sister. I wave at her and she dismisses me going back to dancing with her friends.

She is my older sister so maybe it wouldn't be so bad if they dated. After all she always talks about him.

"I'm pretty sure she has a huge crush on you." I say not thinking about how embarrassed she would be if she found out I told him this.

"Really?" He asks sounding surprised.

"Yeah. Y'all would probably really get along!" I say swallowing the bile in my throat. As much as it grossed me out, my older sister likes him a lot, and Keith is a good guy.

She's 24, only two years older than Keith and I, so I'm sure they'd have a lot in common.

Keith looks at me like he just saw a ghost, taking the beer out of my hand, "Okay, I think you've definitely had too much of this!" He says while laughing.

"No, I'm serious! We have to look out for each other. I know it's hard enough to find a decent girl." I say honestly. Maybe I'm not freaked out about him dating my sister because I am with his sister. I wasn't doing this out of guilt, I just didn't want to be a hypocrite when he found out about Athena and I.

"Thanks, man. I really appreciate it." He says sincerely. "Is it okay if I go talk to her?" He asks.

"Yeah, go for it!" I tell him with Athena being the only thing on my mind. 

✾

Athena had driven us home about an hour ago, and Keith and I had been playing video games ever since we got home. We were both still pretty drunk, so our skills had decreased significantly. 

After a few games, Keith passed out. I, on the other hand, was wide awake. 

"Athena!" I whisper before opening her bedroom door. She wasn't in there. I look around, but don't see here anywhere. However, I do hear water running in her bathroom.

I slightly peak in her bathroom, and sure enough she's in the shower. I can't see her because the shower curtain is blocking my view, so I walk further in her bathroom.

I take my clothes off and get in the shower with her. She's rinsing off her hair so she doesn't notice me yet.

"Dean!" She screams startled.

"Shhh." I say while putting my hand on her mouth, hoping no one heard her.

"What are you doing? Shouldn't you be hanging out with Keith?" She asks.

"No, I should be fucking you." I smirk while pulling her in to a kiss. 

I pull out of the kiss, admiring her beauty. "Wow, your hair is so... brown. It's silky." I say slurring my speech.

Athena laughs at me while playing with my hair. "You are so stupid!" She playfully hits me.

"What? I can't admire my pretty girlfriend?" I say without thinking about my words.

She looks at me completely serious and stops playing with my hair, "Girlfriend?".

"I mean, yeah, why not." I drunkenly shrug, pulling her back into my arms.

"Isn't it kind of soon?" She asks, making me think about my drunken words. 

"Probably, but we've known each other forever and we both like each other." 

"Yeah, I guess you're right." She smiles back at me, making me grow uncomfortably harder. 

"Need help with that?" She looks down at my hard dick.

"I thought you'd never ask." I wink at her.

She gets on her knees while the hot water runs down our bodies. I pull her hair back in my hand,  trying to get her wet hair out of her face.

She slowly sucks the tip while stroking the rest of my dick. I lean my head back on the wall while she takes more and more of my dick with each stroke. 

She finally takes all of it, trying not to choke on my dick, but she fails. "You just like choking on my dick, huh?" I say with a smirk on my face. She nods and continues sucking my dick. 

I pick her back up to where she is now standing. Wow, she's short. I bend down and kiss her neck while bringing my hand down to play with her clit.

She quietly moans, still aware that there are people in the house, but she becomes a little louder as I slip a finger in her. 

I tease her clit while fingering her until she is wet enough to take my dick. 

I push her chest on the shower wall, lining myself up behind her. I tease her with the tip of my dick before I stick it in.

"Oh, Dean." She says under her breath. I could listen to her moans forever.

"Does that feel good, baby?" I ask slowly thrusting inside of her.

She nods at my question, making me spank her ass. "I want to her you say it." I demand.

"Yes, it feels so good." She says trying not to be loud. 

I grab her hair in my fist and tightly pull in my hand to the side, making her neck available. I bite her neck gently and give sloppy kisses, making her continue her soft moans. I could tell she was trying to be quiet because there was people in the house, but I really wanted to hear her moans louder. 

"Harder!" She begs me. I do as she says and thrust hard, but still slow making her want more. Sensing I'm slowing down, she moves her hips back and forth to make up for what I'm not doing.

"Fuck that feels so good." I moan out making her walls tighten. 

She reaches her climax first, moaning my name. Feeling her get so tight caused me to reach my climax right after her. I pull out and cum on her back, the water quickly washing it away. 

"You're lucky I'm on birth control." She says turning around. 

"What, I pulled out?" I shrugged.

"Precum is a thing you know." She rolls her eyes at me playfully. I spank her lightly while pulling her into a hug and kissing the top of her head.

We get out of the shower and get ready for bed. I head to the guest room, knowing it would be too risky to sleep in Athena's bed. 

I wonder how we were going to break the news to Keith about us being together? I quickly stopped worrying as I slipped into a deep sleep.

✾✾✾✾✾

I don't know about y'all but I'm happy Dean and Keith are reconciling!!! Let's just hope that lasts when he eventually finds out about Athena and Dean...

Please vote<333