Alright so I already was going to give more then just one ending. What? You thought I was that evil?😂 Enjoy!

^^Song: Control/ Halsey

You and Dipper's Age: 17

~•~3rd POV~•~

CHOOSING MABEL:

Dipper had told you to meet him at the park. He was nervous out of his mind, but he was also angry and upset.

He's angry because Mabel was making him choose between two people he loves.

He's upset because- he might lose you forever.

When he saw you standing near a park bench, looking around, he could feel tears form in his eyes.

This could be the last time he'll ever see you.

When you noticed he was walking over to you, you turned your head to face him and smiled.

"Hey Dippy!" You said, kissing his cheek, "What did ya want me to come to the park?"

He didn't answer. He put his head down so you couldn't see the tears that started to flood from his eyes. He covered his face with his hands and lightly sobbed.

You were confused to what was happening, but you were there to comfort him.

"Dipper? Are you alright?" You asked.

Dipper finally looked up at you, wiping his eyes.

"What I-I'm about to tell you, could change e-everything. B-But I need to do o-one more thing before I-I say it." Dipper said.

"What is it?" You asked.

Quickly, he held the back of your head and smashed your lips on his, giving you a passionate kiss. It was a salty kiss from his tears, but it was going to have to last.

You two kissed for a good minute, until Dipper slowly pulled back from you.

"(Y/n), we... We need to-" Words refused to leave his mouth.

"We need to what?" You asked.

"W-we... Weneedtobreakup." Dipper said quickly, shutting his eyes.

You heard it though. Your eyes widened slightly, as you took a step away from him.

"So, it was true?" You asked, heartbroken, "You don't love me anymore? Were you cheating on me too?! Was that a lie too?!"

"(Y/n)-" he tried to reach out to you, but you jerked your hand away.

"No! Don't touch me!" You snapped.

Tears went down both of your faces.

"Mabel was right. You don't love me-"

"I'm madly in love with you, (Y/n)!" Dipper shouted, making you shut up.

There was silence.

"T-Then why are you breaking up with me, Dipshit?!" You asked.

"It's... I-It's complicated..." Dipper mumbled.

"I still can't believe you." You said, "After convincing me before that you love me, I don't know if I should trust you again." You mumbled.

There was silence. He tried to walk towards you again, but you took a step away from him.

"(Y/n), please-"

"Goodbye, Dipper." You said, almost in a whisper, tears going down your face, "Maybe we'll see each other again soon."

Before Dipper could do anything, you started to walk away from him, covering your face and crying.

And that's when Dipper broke down into tears.

~•~•~

CHOOSING (Y/N):

Dipper walked over to Mabel outside of the Mystery Shack. She was sitting up against a tree. Mabel heard footsteps coming towards her, so she looked up at Dipper.

"Hey Dip." Mabel smiled, as she stood up.

"Hey..." He mumbled.

"You okay, bro bro?" She asked, tilting her head sideways.

Even if they did have a huge argument, they could never stay mad at each other. But, Mabel kept her word to him to choose who.

"I have something to tell you." He said.

"Okay..? What?" She asked, a smile still on her face.

Dipper went quiet for a while, words refusing to leave his mouth.

"I-I... I'm choosing (Y/n)." He said, shutting his eyes and looking away.

Mabel's smile slowly left her face to shock and heartbrokenness.

"You... What?" She asked.

"I'm sorry Mabel, but I choose (Y/n)."

Tears formed in Mabel's eyes as she stared at her brother.

"How... Why..?" She asked, starting to get angry.

"Mabel, you've never felt love before, so you don't know what it would feel like if I broke up with (Y/n)." Dipper said, "It'll be too painful."

Words refused to leave Mabel's mouth she was so heartbroken and upset. Dipper faced her again, but regretted it seeing the tears going down her face.

"So be it." Mabel said, now with an emotionless face.

"Mabel-"

Before he could do anything, Mabel started to speed walk away, ignoring him.

And that was the last time Dipper saw Mabel.

~•~•~

CHOOSING NEITHER:

Dipper had locked himself in his room for days, thinking of who he should choose. But he couldn't just choose between two people that he dearly loved. If he chose one, the other would be heartbroken.

You started to get worried about him, since you hadn't seen him lately.

Same goes with Mabel.

You went over to the Mystery Shack to go and see if he was there. When you walked through the gift shop door, you saw Mabel sitting behind the counter. You walked up to the counter to talk to her. You were still angry at her for lying to you about Dipper.

"Mabel." You snapped.

She looked at you, "Oh, hey (Y/n)." She said without any of her happiness tone in her voice.

"Where's Dipper?" You asked.

She gave you a confused look, "I don't know. I thought he ran away with you or something"

"I haven't seen him in weeks." You said.

Mabel stood up and walked around the counter, "I haven't see him in weeks too."

You were both started to become concerned.

"Do you know where he is?"

"Last time I saw him he was in his room, but he was talking to himself or something-"

Realization hit you both, as your eyes widened and you both gasped. You quickly rushed to Dipper's room. You opened the door immediately.

"Dipper?!" You both chorused.

Dipper was standing in front of his table, his back to the two of you. You stood in front of Mabel to protect her, as you both slowly walked towards him.

"Dipper?" You asked.

Once you got behind him, you slowly reached out to touch his shoulder. Before you could touch it, he chuckled evilly. You pulled your hand back quickly as you and Mabel took a step back from Dipper.

"D-Dipper?" Mabel asked.

He laughed evilly again, as he slowly turned around to face you. His eyes were yellow now, with black slits.

"Hello, Shooting Star, (Y/symbol)." Bill said, a smirk coming across his face.

Blue flames appeared in his hands, as he stared directly at you two, "Sweet dreams." He said.

The last thing you two saw was a flashing blue light surround you two, and maniacal laughter.

~•~•~

Not all stories have happy endings...

___________

Sorry if I made you cry😂

I had this idea for a while now

I didn't do him choosing both because then there wouldn't have been feels or something tragic that'll make you sit on the edge of your seat

Anyways guys, I hope you all enjoyed this!

~gianna_northwest