Who Watches You Sleep

Aries ~ Jane The Killer

Taurus ~ Lost Silver

Gemini ~ Laughing Jill

Cancer ~ Masky

Leo ~ Nina The Killer

Virgo ~ Eyeless Jack

Libra ~ Rouge

Scorpio ~ Smile Dog

Sagittarius ~ Zalgo

Capricorn ~ Splendorman

Acquarius ~ Bloody Painter

Pisces ~ Nurse Ann

If you want me to include a creepypasta you like that hasn't been mentioned, feel free to say something about them!