CIEL PHANTOMHIVE:

Gifts are a rarity from Ciel. When you do get gifts, they are expensive and meaningful. You usually get them for birthdays, or after something bad happens, as a thank you for staying with him. You'll know Ciel truly does love you, even when he's cold.

SEBASTIAN MICHAELIS:

Sebastian would get you gifts often, practically for no reason. They would be significant, hinting at a memory or special time. Sebastian would not hand them to you directly, but leave them in places he knew you would find. He'll get you flowers, jewelry, clothes, food, and books, anything to make you smile.

ALOIS TRANCY:

Anything and everything. It doesn't matter how expensive it is. Alois once bought you a horse, and when you rejected that, bought a puppy or cat (depending on what you like). He buys it to show you that he loves you (and to show off his wealth).

CLAUDE FAUSTUS:

Claude wouldn't buy something extravagant in his terms, but it would be impressive nonetheless. It would most likely be something you had mentioned months earlier (and had probably forgotten about) when you haven't even thought he was listening—but of course, he was; he always is. The gift would not only be a physical present, but also a bit of reassurance that Claude does love you and care about you, and he is listening even though you think that he never is.

UNDERTAKER:

What gifts?

WILLIAM T. SPEARS:

You only get gifts when it's a holiday or your birthday, so a special date. But when you do, it's always thoughtful and beautiful. William will get you something that you wanted, or something with lots of meaning. He'll give it you awkwardly, but he'll be smiling. 

 ♚ ♚ ♚

QUESTION: Which kind of gifts do you like the most?

AUTHOR'S ANSWER: Books!

What about you?

Edited: 3/11/18